Nicole’s Letter Essay #3: The Giver

Recently, I had the time to re-read the book “The Giver”, an 180-page dystopian fiction novel by Lois Lowry, which was originally published in 1993. I have read this book once before in 6th grade but, felt the need to read it again because I had completely forgotten what it was about. Also, because I just found out that the movie version of “The Giver” came out last year (August 15, 2014) and I always like to compare the movies to the books, even if the books are ALWAYS better than the movies.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJNNugNe0Wo

This novel is about a boy named Jonas growing up in a place of conformity, where there is no pain, color, or freedom, but he doesn’t know that yet.

As you grow up in this community, there are different celebrations, the most important is becoming a 12 because this is when you get your job. But, when Jonas gets the job as The Receiver he is a bit unsure. The Receiver is the person who gets all the old memories of the community and stores them until, they go on to become the Giver. It is a job of bravery because often, it can be quite painful. So, as The Giver entrusts him with the memories he notices what everyone doesn’t know abThe Giverout the real world.

I liked the way the author created this whole new world where people didn’t know what pain was. I find that a little unsettling because imagining me being in a place where their was no wrong decisions, seemed odd. Without having pain, life wouldn’t be as interesting, we would not be able to learn from your mistakes or just experience the world.

Yet, at the same time the idea of this community not being able to see color bothered me so much. I am one of those people that will have an existential crisis at least once a week and this, did not help. Just try to picture going to school yet, not being able to see that the bus was yellow or, that the stop sign was red because, you never know, maybe color is just in our heads. Is it even real?

I loved all those different changes she made to that specific neighborhood but, I absolutely did not enjoy the ending of “The Giver.” The story was flowing so nicely. Getting to see Jonas and The Giver relationship form, hearing about all the different jobs and then BAM, the story ended so fast. I feel as though Lois Lowry should have taken time to add more to the ending because I was left not knowing what had happened.

I understood when The Giver eventually said “The worst part of holding memories is not the pain. It’s the loneliness of it. Memories need to be shared” (154). It made sense why he said this because, yes, the memories themselves were painful but, having to cope with not being able to share the memories with the community was going to be the most painful. All the people in that neighborhood probably have never even heard of color and even if Jonas were to talk about it, no one would understand him. He would be the only one that knew about this whole different life.

This also kinda made sense to me in our life, now, because their are memories that many of us have that, maybe, if you explained it to someone, they would not understand the importance of it.Jonas

I thought this was an amazing book that sort of refreshed my mind with life lessons after reading other fantasy books. I would give this a 8/10.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

3 thoughts on “Nicole’s Letter Essay #3: The Giver

  1. Nicole,
    “The Giver” is one of my all-time favorite books, and I am really beginning to look forward to reading it aloud to your class and my other classes during our upcoming Dystopian Literature unit. I’ve never seen the movie, so thanks for including the trailer; my plan is to show the movie in class after I read the book aloud and discuss the changes that were made and the reasons behind them. . . . Your reflection is very thoughtful, which was appropriate and expected; “The Giver” is meant to force its readers to think, and I expected this from you. I happen to love the ending, and I look forward to our class discussions about the ending. Great letter-essay!
    Sincerely,
    Mr. Jockers

  2. Nicole,
    I have heard that this book is really good but I never have had the time to read it. Your letter essay was really good and makes me want to actually read the book. I really loved how you added the video and picture I thought it added a nice touch to your letter essay.
    Erin

  3. Nicole,
    You did a very nice job reflecting on this book. I read “The Giver” last year and enjoyed it, your reflection might make me read it again! I really liked the quote you picked and how you reflected on it, I thought it really finished your letter essay nicely.
    Alex H.

Leave a Reply to rcjockers Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *